sorry for using caps not meant to be angry or to insulate your wrong.
but let me spell out what i was thinking
turn 1- night- assassin kills
day- everyone votes for themselves-assassins will to because if they dont it
will give them away
everyone gets 1 vote so its a 7 way tie no one dies?? right?? but ambu either
knows at least one person is or is not
an assassin
turn 2 -night- assassin kills again possibly the ambu but unlike as its 1-5 and a 2-5
chance.of picking the one the ambu investigated if not a assassin.
less then 50/50
Day- phase no one votes except for the the ambu if he know who the assassin
if not then no one votes
assassin's may try and push for someone but it doesn't matter now because
the ambu has cleared 2 people
and himself out of 6 remaining players 2 out of the other 3 are assassins
By the end of the second day the
game is over.
So now that i have given the wining strategy away we dont need to play this again right??? the only way the assassins win is if there lucky enough to kill the ambu.
This strategy is broken. The fissure occurs during your second turn: "Day- phase no one votes except for the the ambu if he know who the assassin if not then no one votes ".
1. If no one votes because the ANBU scouted a shinobi, than in the last second one of the assassins will make a vote. It won't matter that the ANBU will know that the one who voted was one of the assassins, he has no way of proving that he is not an assassin himself.
2. If no one votes but the ANBU, that would turn him in the next target of the assassins, making the chances of the assassins to kill the ANBU in 1/1 instead of "1/5".
PS: I don't see how the chances to kill the ANBU from the beginning can be "[..] and 2/5". They can only be 1/5.
Also, I've run through most of tactics that could turn this chance game into a complete strategy game. I couldn't find any plausible strategy and I've simulated over 10 complex strategies.
I passed once through a similar tactic as yours, the result was the same.
I reached the conclusion that there is no other way of playing this game other than how it works at the moment.
Follow @SLO_MMORPG